15 Personalized Easter Gifts to Make the Holiday Extra Special
Updated: Apr. 12, 2023On the hunt for something truly special? From baskets to bunnies, these personalized Easter gifts go that egg-stra mile to show how much you care.
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
Much like spring itself, Easter is a time of rebirth. So why not celebrate new beginnings by creating some new Easter traditions? This year, instead of ordering premade Easter baskets, consider giving personalized Easter gifts with special meaning. Sure, you can still treat recipients to their favorite Easter candy but you can also wow them with Easter basket stuffers meant just for them.
Whether you’re putting together Easter baskets for adults, Easter baskets for kids or Easter baskets for teens, we have Easter basket ideas to make them extra special. These personalized Easter gifts can be customized with a name, an initial or even a quote. They’ll show your loved ones that you really thought about them and, in keeping with the spirit of the season, that just might put a spring in their step.
Best for wrapping it up: Callie Personalized Photo Easter Wrapping Paper
No matter what you decide to give for Easter, you’ll want to wrap it in this personalized wrapping paper that features the recipient’s face, complete with bunny ears. Simply upload a photo, choose from half a dozen colors and–voila!–you have the cutest wrapping paper ever. You’ll laugh when gifts are, for the first time ever, carefully unwrapped rather than torn open.
Best for sisters: Anthropologie Monogram Candle
This stunning scented candle is like a bouquet of springtime flowers, spreading the heady fragrance of Night Gardenia. The glass vessel is a true work of art, hand painted with your sister’s floral-emblazoned initial. Once this scented candle has been burned through, she can use the vessel to hold her jewelry or keys. With a burn time of 71 hours, this treat for the senses will prove that the sibling rivalry is over.
Best for the sweet tooth: Celine Zhou Custom Message Shortbread Cookies
These delicious shortbread cookies are from celebrated French pastry chef Celine Zhou. 24 cookies express your custom message–with them a happy Easter, share an inside joke or remind them that sharing is caring. For an extra touch of nostalgia, present these tasty personalized Easter gifts with a fresh gallon of farm-fresh milk for dunking.
Best for the whole family: Personalized Jumbo Easter Eggs
Up the ante on your Easter egg hunt by having each participant search for an egg that bears their name. Watch how invested they are in finding the special egg you’ve filled with candy and trinkets picked especially for them. The large plastic eggs come in four different colors (with polka dots!) to really stand out. Best of all, they can be used to hold treasures all year round, making them one of the best personalized gifts for everyone in the family.
Best for toddlers: Let’s Make Memories Personalized Furry Critter Easter Basket
As plush and cuddly as a stuffed animal, this oh-so-cute Easter basket will remain a toddler favorite long after they’ve finished the candy you place inside it. The pink and blue bunnies are natural Easter choices, but you can also choose from a unicorn, dog, owl, butterfly, dragon or shark. Each basket is adorable on its own, but the personalization makes it something to treasure.
Best for kids: Personalized Lego Storage Brick Container
Who says an Easter basket has to be an actual basket? Use your imagination and give young builders this cool Lego-shaped storage container so they can use theirs. Fill it with their favorite bricks (and maybe some vintage candies) to keep them nourished while they create. Available in two different colors and sizes, you can personalize it in a variety of font and color choices so siblings will have one less thing to fight over. Pair it with one of these Easter gifts for kids for the ultimate package.
Best for teens: Design-Your-Own Phone Case
That cell phone never leaves your teen’s hand and is probably pretty filthy. Surprise them with a brand new phone case that no one else will have. Upload a photo that’s important to them (maybe a furry family member?) and it will be transformed into a strong and durable silicone rubber case. Not only will this Easter gift protect their expensive phone, but it will make it instantly recognizable when they’re out with friends. You can even add some text–just try not to embarrass them.
Best for moms: Brook & York Custom Name Cuff Bracelet
You can never go wrong with giving jewelry as a special gift for mom–especially when it’s obvious you picked it out just for her. This beautiful statement piece is made in the USA from 14k gold-plated brass, adding a touch of casual sophistication to any outfit. Whether you customize it with her name or “Mom,” this bracelet will be a meaningful piece she’ll wear all the time to show off her love for you.
Best for dads: Spotted Dog Company Personalized Whiskey Glass
The perfect gift for dads who like to relax with a drink, this elegant lowball glass is worthy of his favorite top-shelf bourbon. Use the template to add an initial, a name or a meaningful message, then watch his face light up when he sees the finished product. Whether he’s a half-full or half-empty kind of guy, he will love this custom whiskey glass.
Best for grandmas: Personalized Wooden Easter Bunnies
Featuring all her beloved peeps, this decorative set will take center stage in Grandma’s house. Each grandchild or family member is represented by an adorable bunny. Choose their color and size, add their name and personalize the wooden block to match their personality. She’ll want to display this piece even after Easter is over. (Coincidentally, 2023 is the Year of the Rabbit.)
Best for grandpas: Uncommon Goods Personalized Socks
These personalized socks will warm Grandpa’s feet…and his heart. Add his name, send a special Easter message or simply say, “I love you.” Your message will be custom knit on soft, high-quality Pima cotton, so he’ll feel loved and comfortable. This cozy sock set comes with five pairs and is available in black or gray. Here are more warm socks to keep his drawer stocked.
Best for besties: Mezze Monogram Mug
These glazed stoneware mugs can easily be the most personal of all personalized Easter gifts. Before wrapping, fill them up with jelly beans, affordable trinkets, earrings—even candy based on your bestie’s zodiac sign. Once she’s done enjoying her mini-gifts, she can use this personalized mug for her morning coffee. Each mug features a lovely tiled design, with your friend’s initial starring as the centerpiece. Consider buying one for yourself as well, so you can grab a cup of coffee together.
Best for teachers: Initial Canvas Tote Bag
Teachers are always carrying books, papers, school supplies and a million other things. A sturdy personalized tote is a thoughtful Easter gift that will make their life easier. This generously-sized canvas bag is a workhorse, featuring an outside pocket and top zipper. You can have their initial embroidered within a beautiful floral design, or alone in a simple block font. As stylish as it is practical, this is way better than giving an apple to a teacher.
Best for hosts: Personalized Serving Bowl
If you’re going to an Easter party, you definitely want to bring a hostess gift as a thank you. This gorgeous glazed stoneware bowl will be a much welcome one–even more so if you fill it with Easter candy. Hand-glazed and engraved with text of your choice, it’s microwave, oven and dishwasher safe. Available in three colors, match these personalized Easter gifts to their kitchen decor. They’ll look forward to using these bowls for popcorn while watching their favorite Easter movies.
Best for coworkers: Avito Personalized Tumbler
Support your office’s sustainable living efforts by gifting your co-workers one of these personalized water bottles. The 20-ounce stainless steel tumbler is skinny enough to take up little room on a desk and, thanks to its vacuum insulation, will keep beverages hot or cold for hours. If you’re looking for personalized Easter gifts for the whole office, these reusable water bottles come in 14 colors and are engravable in a variety of fonts.
Stop hunting for the best products and deals—get our expert scoop on secret sales and discounts, gift ideas for everyone and can’t-miss products. Sign up for the Stuff We Love newsletter.
